Impressions from my first week at Bluesky

It’s deeply fun and energizing to be back in an operating role. The team has been very welcoming and impressive. I spent my first week meeting lots of people and soaking up information, both from the Bluesky team and the Bluesky user base (while I don’t post a lot, I do read a ton every day). I’ve been learning about several internal projects that I can’t wait for us to ship. Lots of good stuff ahead for both Bluesky app users and AT Proto developers.

Some observations:

Lots of people seem curious about the size of the Bluesky team. It’s 42 people, and that’s up significantly from just a few months ago. Those numbers surprise many. Yes, this is a small team that has accomplished a lot.

People ask if Bluesky is mostly about liberal politics. It’s not. There’s a strong, active cohort of people who love to talk about politics, but political posts are less than 10% of the network. People talk about every conceivable topic. Other than politics, top topics are music, entertainment, sports, and science.

I’ve been working with Jay for the last couple of years, and I’ve never seen her as happy as in her first week as CIO. She’s diving into some big new ideas, and I can’t wait for you all to see what’s next.

Many messages I’ve gotten from the Bluesky community were along the lines of, “Welcome, this is a great place, please don’t mess it up.” The subtext is that I was brought in to turn things around in some dramatic way. I was not. I like our strategy, and we will continue to deliver on it.

Quite a few people wondered if my arrival means that we will start putting ads on the network. We’re not. We are very actively thinking about how we will make money, but ads are near the bottom of the idea list.

In diving into the makings of Bluesky, I noticed that the AT Protocol that underpins Bluesky feels related to the GPL license that underpins WordPress. Both are “commitment devices”, one technical, the other legal, to ensure that ecosystem participation remains open.

When people tell me, “I love Bluesky, and I’m glad you’re involved,” I sometimes answer, “I love it too—and did you know that Bluesky is one app of many in a network called the Atmosphere?” This has gotten me 100% blank stares. But yes, it’s true. There are lots of other apps in the Atmosphere. Expect me to talk a lot more about that in the coming weeks and months.


Comments

18 responses to “Impressions from my first week at Bluesky”

  1. Brett Avatar

    What is at the top of the list for earning revenue?

  2. Schwager Avatar
    Schwager

    Please install a small monthly fee (i.e. 5 Euro). People who value the platform will stay and you get far enough away from the scenario of using external money (ads et.al.).

    Best regards HW Schwager

    1. AT fan Avatar
      AT fan

      A lot of old schoolers, people just starting out, financially smart people, and those on a constrained budget will refuse to play the subscription game and leave. Also (optimistically) it will cause Bluesky to fall to another @proto service that doesn’t have mandatory subs, but more likely it would kill the project entirely.

      Optional subs are fine without painful feature disparity, though we know how that goes under pressure for increasing profits.

      I’d love to see corporate ATproto builds subsidize the social network. I’ve seen some great ideas from game devs about how they could use it to control their information instead of giving so much power to Steam, discord, wikis, social media, and the press (https://birb.house/blog/the-future-of-games-on-atproto), and as someone from the corporate world, that blog shows me the future for organizations well beyond game studios.

      I’m truly excited about ATproto’s potential to fundamentally change how we do things. Alongside the Red Hat model, there are plenty of financial opportunities for anybody with enough technical understanding and imagination.

      1. Brittany E. Avatar
        Brittany E.

        I think monthly fees when done well, like with Discord Nitro which allows you to add some extra cosmetic things but doesn’t actually change the experience in any meaningful way, are a great way to go. I currently pay for Nitro because I love Discord and the way it operates and I want to continue seeing it succeed. I’d absolutely pay the same for Bluesky to keep it going.

      2. Fifi Avatar

        I agree. I really like the way Automattic makes money. Virtually every service they provide has a free tier, which is very generous with it’s features and more than satisfactory for a personal website or an individual user. They then charge for advanced services targeted towards professional and business users.

        Would make sense for Bsky as well. Charging everybody would shrink it’s total network size, making the whole ecosystem less valuable

    2. Johnny Utah Avatar
      Johnny Utah

      When are you going to be suspending the United States Department of War account for violating your terms of service in regards to violent threats?

  3. Be transparent about your costs and be open to ask for donations, similar to how signal does. Or Wikipedia.

  4. please dont ruin bluesky

  5. Friedman Avatar
    Friedman

    I hope liberal does not mean China…

  6. lrul Avatar

    I am wondering if there are plans to create Protect Accounts. Personally, I consider it a necessary feature as a minimum protective measure against cyberstalking.

  7. Excited to see what’s to come and appreciate the transparency!

  8. Beth Avatar

    Please allow an option so that not just anybody can follow you. Can you create a “request to folllw” option? I have 1000+ bots following me. Of course I block them as they come up but I’m thinking they still see my posts.

  9. Please could you find a way to allow users to remove ourselves from lists. There are some bad actors on here who add people onto multiple lists. These lists act as a way of accusing people of things they haven’t posted about – bigotry, anti trans, racism, etc… Thanks and welcome!

  10. Tomaso Avatar
    Tomaso

    I rely on RSS to trigger me to visit social media sites. The BlueSky RSS is tragic. At least give us a photo along with the text.

  11. […] punto, e la pubblicità è il modo più semplice per generare profitti. Il suo nuovo CEO ad interim, Toni Schneider, ha dichiarato in un post sul blog: “Stiamo riflettendo attivamente su come generare profitto, ma la pubblicità è quasi in […]

  12. Congratulations on the new post, I came here from Bluesky Directory newsletter. recently I read your transparency report. It’s among the best reports and strategy roadmap I have read for a tech company since ages.
    If what you wrote there still holds under you reign then the company is definitely in good hands.

    > There’s a strong, active cohort of people who love to talk about politics, but political posts are less than 10% of the network.

    Very interesting. I will share this stat with someone for sure.

    > but ads are near the bottom of the idea list.

    That’s a honest response. I heard a lot of CEOs said we will never do ads, then they do. 😅

    I suggest you hire/partner with Bob Hoffman (of The Ad Contrarian) as an Ad expert, I think your cooperation you both will result an ad monetization system that is sustainable and humane.

    May your platform be eternally immune from the enshittification disease.

    Amen.

  13. Be great if you could investigate the deep and hostile anti-trans moderation of one of the three biggest communities that built the platform before Jay sold it out to become Walmart Xwitter

  14. […] Impressions from my first week at Bluesky It’s deeply fun and energizing to be back in an operating role. The team has been very welcoming and impressive. I spent my first week meeting lots of people and soaking up information, both from the Bluesky team and the Bluesky user base (while I don’t post a lot, I do read a ton every… […]

Leave a Reply to BrettCancel reply

Discover more from Toni.org

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading